Room 23

A gathering place for those who love the ABC TV show Lost. This blog was started by a group of Fans who kept the Season 3 finale talkback at Ain't It going all the way until the première of the 4th season as a way to share images, news, spoilers, artwork, fan fiction and much more. Please come back often and become part of our community.

Monday, May 5, 2008

The Question is...

Are we talking a simple error, a different scar, or something else entirely?

The Poll is now open for your input. Comments are always a sign of a thoughtful answer. Especially if you choose "Other". We want to know exactly what you mean.


Edshrinker said...

I've digitally blown this up 5 ways to Sunday. It is a scar on the right. But it is not where Juliet laid the blade. So what is going on?

I don't buy "The Island Healed the Scar" bit. And as careful as these guys are...they even know to they can't prop a news clipping now because we'll figure it out.

Maybe the thought Hurley is right - they are not really off the Island. They are still in Wonderland where scars don't exist. Or at least recent scars.

I look very forward to the "OTHER" selections. I'm quite sure you guys can do better than the options I provided.

Node32774 said...

ed, you're overthinking here.

Napoleon Park said...

If the tattoed shoulder in the foreground in Jack then that's Jack's reflection in a mirror. If the scar in the reversed reflection is on his left, then it's on the right side of his body. Isn't that where Juliet operated?
If I'm completely wrong about this, I woke up in the middle of my sleep cycle, peed, took some pills and am heading back to bed, writing this while half asleep.

Edshrinker said...

Nope - not over thinking but Node is right to the extent I read too much on this eppy.

Arguments all over place (like the BuddyTv thing above the poll post)are SURE there was no scar. So, I want to give them their voice. I should have made a 5th category though. Scar is there and right where it should be. My 1st comment is wrong. Nap is right - the mirror is what threw me.

The mirror. I like the irony of that. NOW I am over thinking.

redfishbluefish said...

much better image here:

and, yes, you are definitely overthinking it.

Edshrinker said...

The way Juliet was knitting that sucker up - he sure wound up with a decent scar. She's not even a surgeon. Nice work.

Anonymous said...

I've had my appendix scar on my right side since I was 8. Mine is horizontal - his goes on an angle. Looks ok to me - some of you are overanalyzing this, I think. Kind of like Miles' 3.2 million offer.